Recently, I interviewed Pamela, who has the antibodies for Hashimoto’s and is also dealing with extreme fatigue as well as some digestive issues. We discuss her experience with thyroid hormone replacement, struggles with extreme fatigue, anxiety, and digestive issues, the importance of accurate testing for conditions like SIBO and adrenal health, potential treatment options, the need for a comprehensive approach to managing symptoms, and more. If you would prefer to listen to the interview you can access it by Clicking Here.
Dr. Eric Osansky:
Welcome to another Save My Thyroid audit. I am chatting here with Pamela, joining me from Ohio with her little doggie, Charlie. Nice to talk with you, Pamela. How are you doing today?
Pamela:
Thanks, Dr. O. I’m doing well.
Dr. Eric:
Awesome. Pamela here is dealing with the antibodies for Hashimoto’s. Some of the symptoms she has been experiencing, some of her main challenges: fatigue, along with anxiety, PTSD.
You have also worked with a number of different practitioners. It’s been three functional medicine practitioners? Two or three?
Pamela:
It’s been two, and one is a doctor/coach, non-prescriber.
Dr. Eric:
Can I ask how you found me?
Pamela:
I think just because I was watching other thyroid videos, you came up in my feed. Then I went on your newsletter list.
Dr. Eric:
How long have you been dealing with those Hashimoto’s antibodies? When were you first diagnosed?
Pamela:
My diagnosis was in April of last year. Then I was briefly medicated with T3 only. I had just an awful experience. The doctor kept saying I just needed a higher dose. It got to the point where I wasn’t sleeping or eating. I got a second opinion.
Dr. Eric:
Are you no longer taking the T3?
Pamela:
No. For me, it was a disaster. You just recently sent out a newsletter about thyroid rage. I had that with the T3. It was just terrible. I almost got fired from my part-time retirement job. It was just awful. I am laughing about it, but it was truly the worst of my life as far as medical. I couldn’t eat. I couldn’t sleep.
Dr. Eric:
We were chatting a little bit before, and you said not too long ago, you got a thyroid panel, and your free T3 is looking good. It’s 3.3, which is well within the range. Based on that alone, it seems like at least now, you don’t need any T3, so it sounds like it was a good idea you stopped taking it.
Pamela:
I was relieved to see that. I guess I am converting. As long as I keep the nutrition up and stress down, I shouldn’t need medication at this point. I seem to be going the right way.
Dr. Eric:
That’s great. Not everybody with antibodies for Hashimoto’s needs to take thyroid hormone replacement. A lot of doctors will just put everybody on it. Your body told you that you didn’t need it. Obviously, your recent blood tests show that, too. Your antibodies are still quite high but are heading in the right direction, correct?
Pamela:
Right. I’ve looked at myoinositol and black seed oil. I don’t know if one is considered better than the other or if I just have to experiment with them.
Dr. Eric:
You haven’t taken either one of those?
Pamela:
No, I haven’t.
Dr. Eric:
We could talk about different options with myoinositol. There is some research of how that combined with selenium can potentially help. I actually like black cumin. I can’t say I take it every single day, but I am a fan of black cumin. We will talk about both of those. If I forget, remind me. I want to talk about other things, too, but we will get back to that.
We mentioned some of the symptoms. How long have you been experiencing fatigue for?
Pamela:
That is originally why I went to a functional guy in the first place. I had been treated for hepatitis C. About a year went by, and I was feeling tired and draggy. I didn’t nap every single day. Now I’m napping multiple hours every day and sleeping 7-8 hours a night. Just seems like a lot.
Dr. Eric:
7-8 hours a night, most people should be doing that. But the napping during the day.
Pamela:
Each month, the Fitbit was telling me it was going up, the percentage of days with naps. I’m up to 65% of my days, I need a multiple-hour nap.
Dr. Eric:
Oh wow. A few hours, not just a 20-30-minute power nap.
Pamela:
No, hours. I lose the whole afternoon.
Dr. Eric:
Wow, okay. Definitely need to talk about that.
Is the anxiety better since you’re not on the T3, or is that still an issue?
Pamela:
It’s much better now that I’m not on the T3. Somewhere along the line, phosphatidylserine was suggested for sleep. It had a terrible effect on me. That stuff kept me awake all night. I recently got a Gaba L-theanine product, and it had a little bit of it in there. The same thing started happening, like the first couple hours of my sleep didn’t even register on the Fitbit.
Dr. Eric:
It had the phosphatidylserine supplement in there?
Pamela:
Yeah.
Dr. Eric:
Have you had your adrenals tested? Saliva testing or dried urine testing?
Pamela:
No. He did blood testing that first round last April.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. The reason I ask is because typically, phosphatidylserine is given when someone has higher cortisol at night.
Pamela:
I have very high cortisol.
Dr. Eric:
How do you know you have it at night if you haven’t had it tested?
Pamela:
I don’t know about night. The morning one. First, it went down. Between September and I had it tested again in February, I think, it went from the teens, where it was sort of high, to 28.
Dr. Eric:
Wow. You’re talking about a morning cortisol blood test at a lab?
Pamela:
Yes. I just sent off a 24-hour one because I have a doctor’s appointment coming up.
Dr. Eric:
A 24-hour, is it the urine one, where you collected the urine?
Pamela:
No, the four-point saliva.
Dr. Eric:
Great. It would be interesting. Sometimes, someone will have elevated cortisol in the morning, but at night, it won’t be elevated. That wouldn’t be an indication for the phosphatidylserine. Obviously, there are things you potentially need to do to sleep. You said you sleep 7-8 hours at night. Is it uninterrupted sleep, or do you wake up in the middle of the night and have difficulty falling asleep?
Pamela:
The Fitbit says I’m awake a lot. It has little slashes throughout the night. I am on a medication that is supposed to be lowering the cortisol.
Dr. Eric:
Do you know the name of the medication?
Pamela:
It’s called Clonidine. It used to be called Catapres when it was a blood pressure medication in the ‘80s. I know it from then.
Dr. Eric:
How long have you been on that for?
Pamela:
Since April of this year.
Dr. Eric:
April 2024?
Pamela:
Yes.
Dr. Eric:
About five months or something like that. Have you noticed that helping with your sleep?
Pamela:
Yes. It took a long time for it to kick in. The dosage was increased to .02, and that’s when it really kicked in.
Dr. Eric:
When we are talking about adrenals and cortisol, we have to talk about stress. How has stress been? What are you doing from a stress management perspective?
Pamela:
I don’t really feel stress. That’s the thing. I had a hectic career, and now I’m retired. I’m gardening and playing with my dog and taking art class. It doesn’t seem like I have stress, but my body seems to think otherwise.
Dr. Eric:
It could be other stressors. You mentioned PTSD, so it could be past stressors still affecting the physiology. It could be stealth infections. There could be other factors that affect the adrenals and cortisol, even if you don’t feel stressed.
I will say when I dealt with Graves’, I knew stress was a factor, and it was a different situation. I wasn’t retired and am still not. At the time, I was in denial. I’m not saying you are, but sometimes we don’t know. That’s why it’s good you’re doing the saliva test, just to see what it looks like.
Obviously, you did cortisol in the blood. The only thing with the blood is sometimes, going to the lab itself or getting the blood draw can spike up the cortisol. That’s why it’s not completely accurate. It will be interesting to see what the saliva test shows.
Even if you’re not feeling stressed, you’re retired, it sounds like it’s low stress. If you’re not doing anything to block out time for stress management, it won’t hurt to incorporate deep breathing or something like that.
Pamela:
The Fitbit has some mindfulness exercises I do probably three times a week. I do a little bit of yoga and stretching. And I walk.
Dr. Eric:
Those are all good.
Pamela:
They stopped me from walking for a while. They didn’t want me to do anything that would stress my body in any way. I had to gain weight for one doctor to see me. She told me she wouldn’t see me if I didn’t gain weight.
Dr. Eric:
You had the opposite problem that a lot of people have. You were underweight?
Pamela:
Right. It’s weird because I really don’t feel any Hashi symptoms, except fatigue.
Dr. Eric:
No coldness?
Pamela:
I got tested for infections and mold and lots of different stuff. I feel like I have been through the testing machine.
Dr. Eric:
How did you get tested for mold?
Pamela:
There were plates to put around the house that we sent in. Some swabs in my nose.
Dr. Eric:
Those came back negative?
Pamela:
All that was negative. This was the only house I looked at where the basement didn’t smell musty. We have sprung leaks, but we’re running the dehumidifier and crossing fingers at this point until we can get somebody out to fix the outside wall.
Dr. Eric:
Sounds good. Sometimes, depending on the company you use for the plates, there hopefully was an accurate reading. I’m not saying to do this, but there is urinary testing for mycotoxins that looks at mold in the body to see if you have mold in your body. If that comes up positive, then the question is where is it coming from? If it’s not coming from the house, or is it coming from the house, and you had a potential false negative test with the plates?
Pamela:
The H-pylori thing, I think I had to breathe into something.
Dr. Eric:
The urea breath test?
Pamela:
Then I did a lot of stool testing because I had diarrhea starting with the T3 all the way through March of this year.
Dr. Eric:
That stopped when you stopped the T3?
Pamela:
No, it kept going. I was down to about three foods that I could eat: coconut, pumpkin, and peanut butter of all things. My weight was really dropping. In that year, probably 30 pounds.
Dr. Eric:
You lost 30 pounds?
Pamela:
Yes.
Dr. Eric:
Did they find out why you were losing weight? Are you gaining the weight back now?
Pamela:
No. I am gaining it back now. When I was doing the coaching through the fall, I decided to do an elimination diet with meat. Carbs were the problem; I couldn’t digest them.
Dr. Eric:
You went on a carnivore-type diet?
Pamela:
I went on a carnivore diet. I had to tweak my digestion a little with HCl and enzymes at first, but I gained weight. I feel pretty good, except I can’t get rid of this tiredness.
Dr. Eric:
H-pylori breath test was negative. Did you do a comprehensive stool test, or were they just tests through LabCorps or Quest?
Pamela:
No, it was through Mosaic.
Dr. Eric:
Mosaic Diagnostics. You did their stool test?
Pamela:
Yeah. The report was five pages long.
Dr. Eric:
It looked okay?
Pamela:
It looked okay. Some leaky gut stuff at the time, last fall. I just kept doing those supplements and following the advice on that. My digestion is pretty good. For a while, I could see fat in my stool, undigested fat. That has completely stopped. I think it’s a #4 on the chart, which is normal. What I would call normal poop. That seems to be resolved. Every once in a while, I get diarrhea. Somebody suggested that I take Vitamin A after a fatty meal, and that seems to stop it.
Dr. Eric:
Your gut is better. Maybe not optimal, but it’s improved.
Pamela:
Much improved.
Dr. Eric:
Still experiencing the fatigue. Adrenals, which we spoke about. You’re doing testing on that. Nutrient deficiencies. Have you done an iron panel recently? Not just a CBC.
Pamela:
Not recently, no. Back at the beginning, he did iron and ferritin.
Dr. Eric:
You actually sent those, too.
Pamela:
There was a ferritin in what I sent you.
Dr. Eric:
I think there was also iron. Maybe I’m wrong. There was ferritin. Ferritin didn’t look too bad; it was 62. Maybe there wasn’t iron, just ferritin. It did have iron saturation. This was from last year, September 2023. The iron saturation was 18%. Ideally, you want it to be between 30-40%. 18% is still within the lab range, which is 15-55. Definitely on the lower end. A lot of times, the medical doctors will blow it off because it’s within range. Same thing with the iron. It was 66 when you really want it to be 90-100.
If your iron is low, the questions you want to ask is are you consuming enough iron? If you are eating mostly a meat-based diet, the answer would be yes. You’re not cycling; you’re post-menopause, so you’re not a cycling woman. That is not the issue. Then we’d look at digestion, the gut. Are you digesting everything, absorbing everything?
The stool test, I will say this. I like Mosaic Diagnostics for some of their testing, like their organic acids test. The urinary mycotoxins test, they have a good one. I can’t say I love their stool test. On a scale of 1-10, it’s not a 1, but it’s definitely not a 10; it’s somewhere in the middle. It sounds like it still showed some things. It wasn’t a perfect test.
Pamela:
It had some gram-negative bacteria.
Dr. Eric:
I also think about things like SIBO or SIFO. A stool test would not detect that. Just because you mentioned the weight loss. You were taking the T3, but you said even after T3, you were experiencing weight loss and some diarrhea. It wasn’t just related to T3.
SIBO in some people, not everybody, will cause weight loss, but it could cause diarrhea or constipation, sometimes alternating. A lot of people do have symptoms with SIBO, but not everybody. It’s very common to have bloating and gas. Especially when eating foods that are higher in FODMAPs, like carbohydrates, which you cut out. You’re eating more meat, so it makes me think that it might be something to look into in the future.
Pamela:
I did two rounds of antimicrobials in the fall. I started right after this testing, and then I did another round in December.
Dr. Eric:
Which one did you take? Do you remember?
Pamela:
Designs for Health.
Dr. Eric:
Probably their GI Microb-X?
Pamela:
Microbial, yeah.
Dr. Eric:
I’m not saying that wouldn’t help at all, but SIBO can be challenging. Sometimes, the broad-spectrum antimicrobials don’t work for SIBO but could work for other things in the gut. Like I said, something to consider.
If things are not improving, and if you already have been through the medical route, going to gastroenterologists, and they do their endoscopies, a colonoscopy in this case, wouldn’t show anything. Again, that is usually what they’ll do. The H-pylori you had done.
If you are still not getting answers, even though it’s heading in the right direction, and you feel you can’t introduce these other foods, and you are just relying on a meat-based diet, that is at least something to consider. Maybe there is some overgrowth in the small intestine.
There is a breath test you could do. Mosaic Diagnostics doesn’t offer that, but there are other companies like Genovva and a few others that have the breath test for SIBO. Definitely something to look into.
Let’s see what the adrenals look like. A lot of things can cause fatigue. The stealth infections like Lyme, bartonella can cause that. EBV. Some of these tests for Lyme and bartonella, the tick-borne infections aren’t too accurate. If you look at Lyme at a LabCorps or Quest, many times it will be negative, even if someone has it. I’m not saying you have it. I’m just saying that some labs are more reliable than others.
In your situation, I would say since you already did the adrenal saliva test, which is a test I like, you might as well wait and see what that shows. If that isn’t giving all the answers, then it sounds like the gut still has some work to do potentially. If you are still having diarrhea, then I would look maybe at doing a SIBO breath test. You could also look at maybe doing a retest of the stool test, perhaps using another lab, like doing a GI Map or Genovva GI Effects or other labs that I like.
Like I said, based on what you said, if I had to choose between doing a SIBO test or another comprehensive stool test, I would lean more toward using a SIBO breath test and see what that shows.
Before wrapping it up, you asked me about the myoinositol and the black cumin. I told you I would get back to those. For what you’re experiencing, I don’t think those will be magic solutions to your fatigue. I think you’d have to go beyond those.
There are some studies that show myoinositol and selenium can be beneficial in those with Hashimoto’s, moreso the immune system. To be honest, even someone with Graves’ could take selenium. Even the myoinositol, it seems like it has immune modulating properties.
Same with black cumin. Even though there are no studies on black cumin with hyperthyroidism, and there are one or two related to hypothyroidism, it seems like it’s not directly affecting the thyroid, but the immune system, which is good because that is what you are dealing with with the elevated TPO antibodies. It might help.
I think you will need to go beyond that. The saliva testing that you’re doing, maybe do some initial testing with the gut that we spoke about. It shouldn’t hurt to take those. Just taking those alone is probably not going to be the answer.
Selenium by itself in the research has been shown to lower TPO antibodies. Do you absolutely need to take the myoinositol with the selenium? It’s something we don’t know unless someone tries it out. Some people might take both in combination and see a dramatic decrease in their antibodies. Others, maybe not so much.
Same thing with black cumin. Like I said, I like black cumin. It has a number of different health benefits. I have written at least one if not multiple articles on black cumin. It can help with COVID. I’m a fan of black cumin. It’s not that I am not a fan of myoinositol. One might be beneficial to some extent.
I think you also might need to do additional testing. You already did one of them that I would recommend, the saliva test.
That is where I would go. Let’s wait for the results of the saliva test and see what that shows. If there are a lot of imbalances in cortisol levels, and you do things to address those, and that helps, that’s great. If not, if you’re still experiencing fatigue, diarrhea, or other symptoms, you might need to dig even deeper. Maybe do the SIBO breath test that I mentioned earlier.
Pamela:
Okay. That’s great. Very helpful.
Dr. Eric:
Pamela, thank you so much again for applying to do this audit. It was great having this conversation. I hope everyone also benefited from listening to this conversation. Tune into the next episode.
Pamela:
Thanks so much.